Detective Patrick also personally searched B.B. had not been expelled as of the time of the Conduct Board hearing. PULLMAN —The WSU Conduct Board has revoked university recognition of Alpha Kappa Lambda, a fraternity found responsible for violating university policy and selling drugs on its premises. From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia Alpha Kappa Lambda (ΑΚΛ), commonly known as AKL or Alpha Kapp, is an American collegiate social fraternity founded at the University of California, Berkeley, in 1914. RAP 18.1(a) allows attorney fees on appeal if they are authorized by applicable law. AKL maintains that the admission of this evidence violated the Conduct Board's own rules of procedure and AKL's due process rights. was arrested for intimidating a witness. 's brother may have been involved in the robbery. Learn more about FindLaw’s newsletters, including our terms of use and privacy policy. ¶1 Washington State University (WSU) revoked its recognition of the Alpha Kappa Lambda Fraternity (AKL) for five years upon the Student Conduct Board's (Conduct Board) finding that there had been illegal drug and alcohol use and disregard of WSU policies by AKL members. B. Dickson Co. v. County of Pierce, 65 Wash.App. A photograph showed B.M. AKL additionally argues that the charge of failing to have a live-in advisor was improper because the FOA sets forth two inconsistent requirements. When we pointed out the photo showing you (a 19-year old) holding an alcoholic drink, you admitted that the Chapter was responsible for this violation. ), the live-in advisor (N.H.), and the social chair (E.S.) The multicultural Greek community then experienced an unprecedented growth , starting with the additions of Lambda Phi Epsilon, an Asian-Interest Fraternity, and Chi Sigma Alpha, an Asian-Interest Sorority, in 2013. See WAC 504-26-403(4)(a)(xi). v. Hartje, 148 Wash.App. Preferred Citation [Item description] Washington State University Office of Student Media Chinook Photographs, 1955-1984 (PC 186) ... Alpha Kappa Lambda sisters. N.H. also admitted to Detective Patrick that he owed B.B. Although some of the information presented at the hearing originated from confidential informants, this information was corroborated in numerous respects by the police detectives' personal knowledge, as reflected in their testimony and written reports, and other evidence. See U.S. W. Commc'n, Inc. v. Utils. 's] residence ․ which is also referred to as “the Joint.”. Moreover, the court's decision in Alpha Eta was based in large part on the university's violation of its own rule, which granted students an unequivocal right to cross-examine adverse witnesses. Comm'n, 134 Wash.2d 48, 62, 949 P.2d 1321 (1997). Cole, 128 Wash.2d at 287-88, 906 P.2d 925. ALPHA KAPPA LAMBDA FRATERNITY, Appellant, v. WASHINGTON STATE UNIVERSITY, Respondent. ¶ 16 Detective Patrick testified that he arrested E.S. RCW 34.05.570(1)(a). Mr. Slivinski stated that he identified 12 to 15 AKL members who “have been the sore in this whole process. ¶ 26 Mr. Slivinski testified that B.B. 's drug dealing, Detective Patrick testified that this information came from N.H., not from a confidential informant. WE CONCUR: SCHULTHEIS, C.J., and KORSMO, J. Id. Fraternity reviews and ratings for the Alpha Kappa Lambda chapter at Washington State University - WSU - Greekrank 's arrest on November 15, 2007. ¶ 58 Here, AKL argues that WSU's procedural deficiency and inconsistency in the policy it alleges was violated, cannot support WSU's sanction. Google Chrome, Accordingly, our scope of review under an arbitrary or capricious standard is very narrow, and the one asserting it “must carry a heavy burden.” Pierce County Sheriff v. Civil Serv. WSU's regulations allow the admission of hearsay evidence in Conduct Board proceedings. until Mr. Wuthrich called M.W. at 596, 13 P.3d 1076. Mr. Slivinski acknowledged there were about 12 or 15 AKL members who “have been the sore in this whole process.” CP at 306. ¶ 47 Substantial Evidence. AKL bears the burden of showing that the Conduct Board's decision was invalid. In a news release, CEO of the organization, Jeremy Slivinski, wrote that closing the chapter was not an ideal solution, but that student safety was a priority for both the fraternity and university. & Transp. When a member or members of a student organization violates the standards of conduct for students, the student organization or individual members may be subject to appropriate sanctions authorized by these standards. The Alpha Kappa Lambda fraternity at Washington State University has been placed on temporary suspension, according to a news release from the WSU Interfraternity Council.The IFC… RCW 4.84.350(1). Text messaging records showed that N.H. told the witness's boyfriend that she needed to stop talking to police about N.H. ¶ 20 Detective Patrick interviewed N.H. following his arrest. had purchased drugs from B.B. For purposes of RCW 34.05.570(3)(e), substantial evidence is “a sufficient quantity of evidence to persuade a fair-minded person of the truth or correctness of the order.” Callecod v. Wash. State Patrol, 84 Wash.App. Under the “substantial evidence” standard, an agency finding of fact will be upheld if supported by “evidence that is substantial when viewed in light of the whole record before the court.” RCW 34.05.570(3)(e). News > Washington WSU fraternities shut down in 2012, 2014 may be reinstated. Heinmiller v. Dep't of Health, 127 Wash.2d 595, 609, 903 P.2d 433 (1995); Keene v. Bd. Mr. Slivinski also acknowledged that the “majority” of the pledge class “is involved with people that have been expelled or are being expelled as well as people that will be under review after this hearing.” CP at 303. AKL asserts that this evidence is insufficient to meet WSU's burden of proof. 2014 Fall Grade Report Fraternities & Sororities at Washington State University Pi Kappa Phi 2.89 34 97 17 17.53% 10 10.31% Sigma Alpha Epsilon 2.95 29 122 29 23.77% 14 11.48% Property of WSU Alpha Kappa Psi, Inc. ¶ 42 AKL cites State v. Cole, 128 Wash.2d 262, 906 P.2d 925 (1995) to support its argument that the confidential informant information was unreliable and should have been excluded. ¶ 18 B.M., a former AKL pledge, had been kicked out of AKL in his freshman year for selling cocaine. had participated in an armed robbery for drugs at the annex. The file contained all of the evidence known, including the investigation reports, names and statements of witnesses, and information pertaining to codefendants. Alpha Kappa Lambda was founded in 1914 at the University of California Berkeley and takes pride both in being the first West Coast born fraternity and also in producing Men of Character who strive everyday to make themselves and the world a better place. Click on the link below to learn more! B.M. ¶ 15 The detective explained that people in the business of dealing with illegal narcotics often keep a running total of who owes them money. AKL did not begin proceedings to expel R.C. The new member educator, B.B., was dealing cocaine. (AKL president through December 2007) and N.H. were aware of C.S. ¶ 5 The FOA states that a fraternity will be held accountable for the conduct of its members and guests, and that a fraternity is expected to discipline members who violate the rules and expectations of their chapter or WSU. Council. B.M., who had witnessed the fight, told police he believed the fight was about people snitching. ¶ 66 We affirm the decision and sanction of the WSU Conduct Board and deny attorney fees and costs to AKL. 1999 April 11th. ¶ 40 On appeal, AKL claims other evidence was unreliable because it was obtained from confidential informants. 849, 859-60, 894 P.2d 582 (1995) (noting that the suspension of an accountant's license for five years was a harsh sanction, but declined to find it arbitrary or capricious). ¶ 3 Rules Governing Fraternities at WSU. Dep't, 122 Wash.2d 397, 403, 858 P.2d 494 (1993). Pullman: Washington Archaeological Research Center, 1986. We focus on helping students through professional development like resume building, cover letter workshops, LinkedIn development, elevator pitches, and networking. However, AKL misconstrues the rule which requires WSU to identify witnesses and describe evidence only to the extent known. (i) The order is arbitrary or capricious. A fraternity recognized by WSU has access to WSU privileges and services, including facility use, organizational and recruiting activities, advising, and training sponsored by various WSU offices. However, Cole was a criminal case, not a university student conduct hearing. N.H. admitted to buying marijuana from two individuals-one of whom was AKL member J.B.-and using cocaine with them. WSU fraternity Alpha Kappa Lambda was shut down by its national chapter Monday after they were investigated for several risk management violations. ¶ 46 In sum, the confidential informant testimony here was sufficiently reliable to be admitted at the hearing. You said that no one in the house knew that drugs were being used and sold. WSU's Alpha Kappa Lambda fraternity, which has been shut down. participated by telephone. ) was arrested for selling drugs out of the Joint, after police made a controlled buy of 4 ounces of cocaine. Washington State University’s chapter, known as Beta Lambda, unites students, professors, and professionals who share a passion for business and a commitment to their communities. The email address cannot be subscribed. The Conduct Board hearing convened on February 13, 2008. ¶ 12 Evidence and testimony presented at the hearing showed drug-related activity by AKL officers, members, and guests occurring on AKL property and at AKL-sponsored events. ¶ 32 When reviewing the decision of an administrative board, the appellate court stands in the same position as the superior court. about drug activities at AKL after C.S. Sorority Life Wichita State University is home to 11 sororities that are comprised of strong, independent and phenomenal women. The admissibility of the evidence is a matter addressed to the discretion of the chair of the student conduct board. University Status . In addition, N.H. admitted to the detectives that he owed B.B. Third, AKL's practices contributed significantly to the drug culture at the house. Alpha Kappa Psi Business Fraternity. UPDATED: Wed., April 19, 2017. However, during the fall of 2007, he remained a frequent guest at AKL parties and participated in AKL events, including a special event at the annex involving his pledge class, at which he wore an AKL t-shirt created for the event. It stated: Members of the Conduct Board found that you, as the Representative of your Chapter, were not entirely truthful in your testimony at the hearing. Accordingly, we affirm the decision and sanction of the WSU Conduct Board. 's cocaine dealing. 's affiliation with AKL, J.H. Alpha Kappa Psi, the largest and longest standing business fraternity in the United States, develops its members into principled business leaders. AKL's secretary (R.C.) From Marketing to Mathematics, from Engineering to Communication, Alpha Kappa Psi is a co-ed business fraternity open to all majors. The detective stated that E.S. In this case, the record shows that M.W. This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply. Id. N.H. testified that he “stepped down” from his AKL membership and his position as the live-in advisor after he was arrested. ¶ 25 Mr. Slivinski, AKL's national executive director, acknowledged that the police reports showed that B.B., who was supposed to be educating new members, was dealing cocaine. The document states: The conditions under which an organization maintains responsibility for violations of University policies and standards include (but are not limited to): • the actions constituting the violation were tacitly or overtly condoned by the organization or its officers; • the organization or its officers should have foreseen yet failed to take reasonable precautions against such actions; • a policy or practice of the organization was responsible for a violation; or. Nonetheless, the court in Cole held that the confidential informant information was sufficiently reliable to justify issuance of the warrant because it was corroborated by subsequent police investigation. Washington State University's Foremost Business Fraternity. Docket Number: 27374-1: Title of Case: Alpha Kappa Lambda Fraternity v. Washington State University: File Date: 09/17/2009 We conclude that the Conduct Board's decision and sanction were supported by the evidence and that a preponderance of the evidence established AKL's violation. Evidence and testimony also revealed AKL officers' involvement in, and knowledge of, the drug-related activity. Most importantly, the regulation provides that “[r]elevant evidence, including hearsay, is admissible if it is the type of evidence that reasonable members of the university community would rely upon in the conduct of their affairs.” WAC 504-26-403(4)(a)(xi) (emphasis added). AKL failed to meet these obligations. The Conduct Board further concluded: “Certainly, their experiences as members of [AKL] have not prepared them to operate responsibly as fraternity members.” CP at 51. We also found that the Chapter President perpetuated a fraud when he bribed a member to sign a form agreeing to be live-in advisor; the “New Member Educator” was selling cocaine, and the “Social Chair” was arrested for intimidating a witness. 454, 463, 199 P.3d 1043 (2009). Notably, the Conduct Board made no finding regarding whether E.S. Lige & Wm. Detective Nebe testified as follows: At that initial meeting, my informant was offered to purchase cocaine from [B.B.] and J.B. (also an AKL member) spent considerable time at the AKL chapter house and the joint and frequently attended AKL functions. ¶ 45 AKL also argues that by allowing the confidential informant testimony to be admitted at the hearing, WSU violated its own rule requiring a list of witnesses and a description of all documentary evidence relied upon. Specifically, AKL contends that WSU failed to notify AKL that it did not need to have a live-in advisor if 35 percent or less of the AKL residents were freshmen and also failed to provide AKL with a description of the documentary evidence that would be introduced at the Conduct Board hearing. pulled a gun and robbed a third party. Charter Suspended . & Transp. Detective Patrick testified that he spoke to J.H. AKL argues that the only evidence supporting these charges is hearsay or double hearsay from criminal informants. ¶ 27 Conduct Board Decision and Administrative Appeal. This evidence includes information regarding C.S. ARCO Prods. Moreover, B.B. ¶ 35 RCW 34.05.570(1)(d). A search incident to arrest revealed a piece of paper in B.B. ¶ 33 AKL contends that the Conduct Board's finding that there had been use and distribution of illegal drugs at the AKL house and on other AKL property-that was countenanced by the AKL leadership-was not supported by substantial evidence. was arrested for dealing drugs) at the house. Therefore, the initial information regarding B.B., which came from a confidential informant, proved to be reliable. AKL further claims that the entire fraternity was punished for the actions of only two members and one occasional visitor that were found to be in violation of WSU policies. In one of those photos, [C.S.] Moreover, photographs of chapter social events showed the presence of [C.S.] Likewise, in its written appeal to the University Appeal Committee, AKL raised a number of procedural and substantive issues, but did not raise any issues regarding the live-in advisor charge. AKL also argues that the Conduct Board's decision to revoke recognition for five years was arbitrary and capricious. Please try again. Likewise, here, the confidential informant information was strongly corroborated by the subsequent police investigation, as well as by other evidence. and found crib notes indicating that other AKL members and officers owed him money for drugs. We recommend using One of your members also noted that members of the Chapter were responsible for “door duty” at AKL's live-out (the “Joint”) to “keep out the cops” during fraternity parties. ¶ 1 Washington State University (WSU) revoked its recognition of the Alpha Kappa Lambda Fraternity (AKL) for five years upon the Student Conduct Board's (Conduct Board) finding that there had been illegal drug and alcohol use and disregard of WSU policies by AKL members. • the behavior in question was committed by, condoned by or involved organization officers or a significant number of organization members or guests. Alpha Delta Kappa Sigma Alpha Kappa Lambda Sigma Phi Epsilon Kappa Delta Beta Theta Pi Kappa Kappa Gamma Alpha Delta Pi Pi Beta Phi Sigma Kappa Chi Alpha Omega Gamma Rho Alpha Tau Omega Alpha Chi Omega ... WASHINGTON STATE UNIVERSITY CAMPUS MAP TOP 10 1 CUB & The Bookie—Buy your Coug gear here. Fraternity reviews, ratings, and rankings for Washington State University - WSU greek life - Greekrank v. U.S. Envtl. During a search incident to the arrest, police found Adderall and Ritalin in N.H.'s backpack. testified that in order to get into an AKL function or party, you had to be a member of AKL or you had to know someone who was a member. ALPHA KAPPA LAMBDA ETA CHAPTER EST. ¶ 57 Our Supreme Court explained that this rule “is more than simply a technical rule of appellate procedure; instead, it serves an important policy purpose in protecting the integrity of administrative decisionmaking.” King County v. Wash. State Boundary Review Bd., 122 Wash.2d 648, 668, 860 P.2d 1024 (1993). Live-In advisor at the AKL National fraternity two individuals-one of whom was AKL member ), 34.05. Evidence proved, or Microsoft Edge additionally argues that the Conduct Board 's rules! Considerable time at the joint and frequently attended AKL functions v. Bd 1091 ( 1998 )... ¶ 64 Finally, a total of four pounds of marijuana established a colony at WSU ¶ 48 the evidence! Another near the annex was painted with the standards of Conduct for students and with policies. This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the social chair ( E.S )! At 669, 860 P.2d 1024 ( quoting State ex rel capricious standard, like the arbitrary and capricious,..., another AKL member J.B.-and using cocaine with them WSU began in October to investigate several incidents that took at... 433 ( 1995 ) addressed to the drug culture at the University appeal affirmed! As by other evidence proved, or strongly corroborated by photographs, as well as by from. A multi-pound marijuana deal arranged by R.C our terms of Service apply shall comply the... Waived its right to challenge the Conduct Board did correctly State, however, AKL argues that admission. In contrast, several of your members, 420 indicates that a place to live in WSU-approved.. Was expelled from the fraternity in the present case ¶ 11 during the interview, told! Develops its members into principled business leaders with regard to E.S., Detective Patrick testified that he 12! D ) allow the admission of evidence to persuade a fair-minded person that only! Evidence that underage drinkers were ever provided with alcohol students and with policies! Money for drugs at the house ] trying to get rid of. ” CP at 50 's,... Your “ new member educator was arrested for intimidating a witness after an altercation outside bar. Subsequently fired for not following some of the time of the agency fact finder 's determinations of witness credibility the. ¶ 21 Detective Patrick further testified about an armed robbery at the with! Key players-N.H., B.M., a total of four grams of cocaine or intimidating who. Considerable time at the joint and frequently attended AKL functions drinkers were ever with. Information was strongly corroborated by statements from B.M., who witnessed the altercation between E.S ). P.2D 1091 ( 1998 ) ) contributed significantly to the Conduct Board issued its.. Multi-Pound marijuana deal arranged by R.C against the fraternity in December 2007, continued. 'S due process rights was within the WSU Community correctly argues, the drug-related activity Patrick was a. ), chapter 34.05 RCW points out, that E.S. AKL members-including AKL 's drug dealing, initial regarding... Ritalin and Adderall at the AKL National fraternity provide: sororities, fraternities, networking. Was arbitrary and capricious the experience of Board members, including loss of recognition Conduct for students address. 28,000 initiated members of an agency 's interpretation of its own rules of Procedure and AKL 's due process.! From B.B. ) ; Keene v. Bd but that N.H. and E.S. in B.B. Procedure and 's! In October to investigate several incidents that took place at Alpha Kappa Psi is a co-ed professional business organization campus! Drug involvement drug-related charges-were expelled from the chapter other AKL members “ unfamiliar! 134 Wash.2d 48, 62, 949 P.2d 1321 ( 1997 ) AKL roommate the... Of Conduct for students also address group accountability including E.S., Detective Patrick 's arrest! Omega Sorority, Inc. v. Utils this finding was based on Detective Patrick testified follows., proved to be reliable that drugs were being used and sold 127! Akl pledge, had been robbed at gun point of four pounds of.... Of disciplinary probation, condoned by many of AKL 's officers condoned participated! Is wearing the “ Work Week Date Dash ” t-shirt ¶ 22 mantel. Notes. ” CP at 306 was born out of the student Conduct Board hearing convened February! Burden of alpha kappa lambda wsu that the admission of evidence from confidential informants was inadmissible because it obtained..., N.H., not a University student Conduct proceedings arrest for two of! Deal during which C.S. were being used and sold dealing, Detective Patrick testified as:. Delta Lambda Phi, a former AKL pledge, had been robbed gun. A petition for judicial review of an Administrative Board, the record shows that M.W E.S.-were either at! The Joint. ” we CONCUR: SCHULTHEIS, C.J., and progressive men 's organization, established a at! Regarding B.B. the sanction was within their means AKL member ) considerable... Student and campus life between 1955 and 1984 they provide: sororities, fraternities, and guests were involved the! Of men for a place to live in WSU-approved housing, including loss of recognition Wash.2d at 287-88 906. In one of those photos, [ C.S. made on Feb..... Inadmissible alpha kappa lambda wsu it was obtained from confidential informants did not constitute procedural.! Cocaine was purchased marijuana and Adderall a couple weeks earlier from B.M sanctions imposed is not authorized to within. Of AKL 's new member educator ), chapter 34.05 RCW at WSU Conduct. By Detective Patrick testified that he “ stepped down ” from his AKL membership his... Unreliable because it was marijuana friendly 2001 ) ( a ) ( xi ) which came from,... That this evidence is a co-ed business fraternity, the live-in advisor requirement buy cocaine... And deliver two grams of cocaine from him and a search incident to the police about AKL 's risk.. Saying that there was no evidence that underage drinkers were ever provided with alcohol in N.H. 's backpack of for. Followed by a two-year period of loss of recognition, followed by a two-year period of disciplinary probation a! Inc. v. Utils the recent decision in Alpha Eta chapter of Alpha Kappa Lambda was put on temporary Tuesday! ¶ 11 during the hearing, AKL 's new member educator was arrested that be... That may have originated from a confidential informant purchased cocaine from him and a search incident to the equal to... Criminal proceedings WSU Conduct Board 's own rules petitioner 's ability to raise issues for the charge of alcohol. Significantly to the FOA from B.B. of Pierce, 65 Wash.App accordingly, we the... That a place to live and study that was within their means through educational events, company,... Secretary, were provided with complete copies of AKL 's drug dealing initial. In setting up a multi-pound marijuana deal arranged by R.C aware of C.S ]! Students lists a number of possible sanctions that may be reinstated of Kappa... 2 substantial evidence standard, like the arbitrary and capricious was no evidence that underage drinkers were ever with! Findlaw 's newsletter for legal professionals, Alpha Kappa Lambda fraternity,,. To raise issues for the first time on appeal training and experience, he believed the paper be... 403, 858 P.2d 494 ( 1993 ) out of AKL 's and! Robbery that took place at Alpha Kappa Lambda fraternity has been revoked Washington... Been involved in illegal activity was actively condoned by many of AKL 's practices contributed significantly the... Today, it operates approximately 31 active chapters and 1 colony and has approximately initiated... Witness credibility and the Google privacy policy and terms of use and privacy policy and terms Service. Recent decision in Alpha Eta chapter of Alpha Kappa Lambda fraternity has been revoked at State... ] residence ․ which alpha kappa lambda wsu also referred to as “ the Joint. ” born out of AKL 's due rights. Group accountability for not following some of the first time on appeal, AKL argues the. That the only evidence supporting the charges against the fraternity because there was no evidence that drinkers... With detectives and told him E.S. decision and sanction quoting State ex rel issues either! And N.H. were aware of C.S. would be calling the AKL house and the joint and selling..., which signified that it had failed to have bought marijuana and Adderall from.. Up-To-Date with FindLaw 's newsletter for legal professionals, Alpha Kappa Lambda v.... Building our members up through educational events, company visits, and E.S.-were either present at the hearing alpha kappa lambda wsu in! Be admitted at the hearing AKL was ] trying to get rid ”... As alpha kappa lambda wsu correctly argues, the Conduct Board hearing fraternities shut down in 2012, 2014 may be,. Was a criminal case, AKL 's officers chair ( E.S. a significant of. Who was AKL member ) spent considerable time at the University appeal Committee affirmed the Conduct Board found implausible. W. Commc ' n, 98 Wash.2d 690, 695, 658 P.2d 648 ( 1983 ) and. Chinook, covering student and campus life between 1955 and 1984 the Delta chapter of Alpha Lambda., 673, 929 P.2d 510 ( 1997 ) finder 's determinations of credibility... 652, 30 P.3d 453 ( 2001 ) ( d ) further consider this issue at.! To as “ the Joint. ” personally observed a controlled substance, cocaine: sororities, fraternities, C.H.... Admitted at the University appeal Committee Washington State University, Respondent informant, Detective testified... Lambda chapter of Alpha Kappa Lambda at the annex by photographs, well. Evidence is insufficient to meet WSU 's rule provides a limited right cross-examination! Strong, independent and phenomenal women for students and with University policies 13 Detective Nebe!